Home › Identifying › How testing works, and what it can and cannot tell you

How testing works, and what it can and cannot tell you

By · Updated

Testing is the cheapest step in the whole subject and the one people skip. It is also the only step that replaces an argument with a fact.

('

Asbestos identification in Australia is a laboratory result, not an opinion. A physical sample is analysed — normally by polarised light microscopy with dispersion staining — and the report names the fibre type found, or states that none was detected. That report is what building surveyors, removalists, insurers and regulators act on. Nothing else carries the same weight.

The two halves people conflate

There is a difference between taking a sample and analysing it, and almost all the risk sits in the first half.

Taking a sample means deliberately breaking a small piece off a material you suspect of containing asbestos. Done carelessly — dry, indoors, with a power tool, without containing the debris — it is precisely the disturbance this whole subject is about avoiding. This is why sampling is normally treated as work for a licensed asbestos assessor or an occupational hygienist, and why most laboratories will tell you the same thing when you ring them.

Analysis, by contrast, is routine and quick. What matters is only that the laboratory holds NATA accreditation for asbestos identification — that is the national accreditation system, and it is the word to look for.

What a report actually says

Expect three things: the sample reference and where it came from, the result (fibre type identified, or no asbestos detected), and the method used. Fibre types you may see named include chrysotile, amosite and crocidolite.

What a single result does not do is clear a house. It clears that sample. A negative on the bathroom lining says nothing about the eaves, the meter box or the vinyl under the carpet, because they are different products from different years. If the question is “what is in this property” rather than “what is this sheet”, the document you want is a survey covering the whole building.

Home test kits

Kits sold to consumers generally consist of sampling materials plus prepaid laboratory analysis — that is, the analysis is still done by a laboratory. Two things are worth understanding before buying one. First, the kit does not remove the risky half of the job: you are still the person breaking a piece off the wall. Second, the value of the result depends entirely on whether the analysis is done under NATA accreditation, so that is the thing to check on the box rather than the price.

Products that claim to identify asbestos instantly, on the spot, without laboratory analysis, should be treated with deep suspicion. There is no reliable field test.

When testing is worth it, and when it is not

Testing earns its keep when a decision depends on the answer: you are about to renovate, the material is damaged, you are buying, a tradesperson has refused to work until it is cleared, or you need to know which licence class a removal falls into.

It earns much less when the material is intact, undisturbed and going to stay that way. In that situation the practical answer is often to assume it may contain asbestos and manage it accordingly — leave it alone, keep it painted and in good condition, and record what you know for whoever owns the house next. That is a legitimate and common approach rather than a way of avoiding the question.

One case overrides all of this. If the material is friable — crumbly, powdery, or loose-fill insulation in a ceiling space — do not sample it, do not enter the space, and get licensed advice. That is the one situation where curiosity is genuinely dangerous.

', 0)

Frequently asked questions

Can I take the sample myself?

Taking a sample means deliberately breaking a piece off material you suspect contains asbestos, which is the disturbance the rest of this subject is about avoiding. It is normally treated as work for a licensed asbestos assessor or occupational hygienist, and that is what most laboratories will recommend.

What makes a laboratory the right one?

NATA accreditation for asbestos identification. That is the national accreditation system, and it is what makes a result count for surveyors, removalists and regulators.

Does a negative result clear my house?

No. It clears that sample. Different products in the same house come from different years, so a negative on one lining says nothing about the eaves, the meter box or the flooring. For a whole property you need a survey, not a single sample.

Are instant asbestos detectors real?

There is no reliable on-the-spot field test for asbestos. Consumer kits are essentially sampling materials plus laboratory analysis, and their value depends on that analysis being done under NATA accreditation.

Sources

What this page explains is based on these official sources. If you check one and it does not match what you read here, send it to us and the article gets corrected.

Keep reading